Low bids on Va. highway projects reflect tight economic times
Virginia's first batch of federal highway stimulus projects came in 22 percent below state estimates of their cost.
The lower-than-expected prices mean the state can put more stimulus work on the street.
"We'll be able to get another bunch of paving contracts out," state Transportation Secretary Pierce R. Homer said.
While a good deal for the taxpaying public, the unusually low bids also reflect the tough economic conditions that the federal stimulus program is aimed at countering.
"You're seeing high competition in the market," said Malcolm T. Kerley, the Virginia Department of Transportation's chief engineer, "and you're also seeing the fact that there's minimum work in other sectors."
Contractors vying for Virginia highway jobs "are bidding them fairly close," Kerley said. "They want to make sure they stay in business."
With 288,900 people out of work, Virginia's unemployment rate was 7 percent in March, the most recent month for which figures are available.
The first 10 stimulus paving projects the state awarded yesterday totaled $39.1 million. The Transportation Department had estimated that all 10 would cost $49.9 million.
According to VDOT, the state has $4.7 billion of pressing roadand bridge-repair problems. Virginia is due to receive $694.5 million in federal transportation stimulus funds.
"But for the stimulus money," Homer said, "many of these [highway] contractors would go out of business."
Work on the stimulus contracts awarded yesterday could begin within the next month, officials said.
Bids coming in well under cost projections represent a national trend, said Jeffrey C. Southard with the Virginia Transportation Construction Alliance.
Highway companies have been submitting bids recently for jobs around the country that are 15 percent to 20 percent below project estimates, Southard said. "You have contractors very hungry to work."
Among the stimulus projects the Commonwealth Transportation Board awarded yesterday were contracts for a $2.1 million repaving of portions of U.S. routes 360 and 460 in Dinwiddie and Amelia counties, and a $3.2 million repaving on part of U.S. 460 in Prince Edward County.
The board also agreed to apply stimulus funding to a $10 million project to improve passenger train movements through the Acca rail yard in Henrico County and a $3.3 million proposal for drainage improvement on German School Road in Richmond.
This month, Virginia became the last state to obligate funds for stimulus projects, but yesterday the Commonwealth Transportation Board acted to hurry some of the federal money into the economy.
The board gave state Transportation Commissioner David S. Ekern authority to award a group of larger-value stimulus contracts if the bids come in below their estimated costs.
"It would save us about two or three weeks" in starting work, Kerley said.
"We're supposed to be dealing with shovel-ready projects," said Transportation Board Member Gerald P. McCarthy of Richmond. "We have the money. Let's get on with it."
Contact Peter Bacqué at (804) 649-6813 or
.
Advertisement
Reader Reactions
Anon: Most of the low bidders were Virginia contractors. You can find the bid results on the VDOT website at: http://www.virginiadot.org/business/resources/const/bidresults_042909.pdf
Now, if the Chesterfield Board of Supervisors would only wake up, we could lower the cost of bureaucracy now and for the next twenty years.
Specifically, during Chesterfield’s boom years of 2002-2006 and while white-collar labor was tight, Lane Ramsey went out and loaded the upper echelon of administrative staffs while bidding egregious salaries and fringe packages.
It’s time to repost ANY job filled from that era. The savings would be enormous.
Case in point, the Director of Economic Development position was filled by a novice at a wage, benefit, and fringe package approaching $300,000/year. In today’s economic climate, a higher caliber professional would gladly take the job at a package less than $200,000.
Wake up!
As a Commercial General Contractor here in Richmond, I can verify that this has been happening across the building industry. In a few instances, we even estimated a job UNDER COST just so we did not have to layoff any employees! This is why it is so important that the banking industry start loaning again. We know good times will come back around but how long can we wait… paying our clients to do their work?!
I would be interested to know how many bids were received for each job compared to “normal”. How many bids came from out of state firms. How many out of state firms won contracts.
Post a Comment(Requires free registration)
- Please avoid offensive, vulgar, or hateful language.
- Respect others.
- Use the "Flag Comment" link when necessary.
- See the Terms and Conditions for details.


Advertisement