Letters to the Editor, cont’d, June 9
It's Time for America To Quit Making Cars
Editor, Times-Dispatch: Maybe it is time for the U.S. to get out of the auto manufacturing business. We don't seem to be particularly good at it, and we can't seem to do it profitably. Blame it on the unions, the greedy executives, dunder-headed bureaucratic over-regulation, or whatever you want. They are all part of the problem, and will never change. The result is still the same. For the money, Asian car companies have us beat, hands-down. When China figures out how to get into the market, we will be completely left in the dust.
At one time our cars and their manufacturers were the envy of the world. Now they are becoming an embarrassment. Why should we wait for the federal government's involvement to prove that beyond a shadow of a doubt? Why not cut our losses and allocate our human and financial resources to areas where we excel -- like technology, medicine, and education?
Let's focus on what we do well, and let other countries do likewise.
Rick Vogt.
Richmond.
Spy Pros Know Torture Doesn't Work
Editor, Times-Dispatch: For decades, the CIA and the FBI have trained their field interrogators to use the Informed Interrogation Approach (manipulative verbal skills), which has been proven faster and more reliable than Middle Ages torture such as waterboarding.
Orin Deforrest, a CIA agent, used this approach in Vietnam, setting up the best intel group of that war. Col. Stu Herrington used "rapport-building" in Panama that caused Manuel Noriega's henchmen to spill key secrets. Ali Soufan, an FBI agent who interrogated hundreds of al-Qaida suspects, got Abu Zubaydah blabbing within the first hour, before CIA "contractors" clammed him up with waterboarding.
Bob Baer, with more than 20 years with the CIA in the Mideast (Iraq); Eric Maddox, who got info to find Saddam Hussein; Matthew Alexander, who got intel that led to the killing of al-Qaida leader al-Zarqawi; and former chief of CIA European ops Tyler Drumheller all have stated that torture is slow, not reliable, and strengthens our enemies.
No experienced CIA nor FBI field interrogator has testified that waterboarding and other forms of torture work better than manipulative verbal skills. For the "ticking time bomb" scenario, torture is not the choice by CIA nor FBI experts. Too slow. Not reliable.
It appears when waterboarding was tried, it was done by CIA contractors, not by CIA personnel. Why would Dick Cheney, who knows CIA techniques work faster and are more reliable, push CIA to use contractors to gain false statements?
Tom Little.
Glen Allen.
Elder Care Carries Heavy Price for Young
Editor, Times-Dispatch: Correspondent of the Day Roger Galbraith praised our health care system, citing his father's experience of having two artificial hips by age 64 -- which were made possible by a health insurance policy, a hospital that took the operation and the risk, and the company that developed the hip. The cost of this procedure totaled more than $40,000. Galbraith said that he is happy with our current system, and does not want changes made to it at this time.
What is missing in the telling of the miracle that allowed his father to walk again is the part played by the backbone of our health system: Medicare for seniors. When Medicare began, no one could have prophesied that today, millions of our elderly would have hip and knee replacements, extensive heart operations, free motor scooters, and expensive diabetes care at little cost to them; and it is the payment for these life-extending practices that has swallowed up the revenue from taxes on the jobs of our younger generation. The outgo far exceeds the income -- and is why Medicare will eventually become bankrupt.
So, the future is no longer rosy for seniors, and is murky for baby boomers and anyone younger. Changes must come about, and even I, as a senior, can see that we will not fare as well if all are provided for. It will take much deliberation to come up with a good plan. My hope is that some consideration will be made for those who watch their weight, practice good nutrition, exercise, take vitamins, and who make every effort to see that their bodies do not break down before the twilight of their years.
Mildred H. Allen.
Chesterfield.
Small Businesses Need Help, Too
Editor, Times-Dispatch: Unemployment is at a high, the stock market is low, and money is tight across the country. Companies are folding every day, and the mom-and-pop shops that made this country are folding. However, billions continue to flow to save banks and car manufacturers. Explain to me how in these dire times our leader, President Barack Obama, can hop a plane from Washington to New York for a night out with his wife at the nation's expense.
I seem to recall statements referring to these hard times and that we all must sacrifice to make it better in the end. The president needs to practice what he preaches. If the citizens and companies of this country are to work together and sacrifice where they can, then he must not continue to flaunt his power at our expense. It is not acceptable in these times.
People come to this country to the American dream of making it big. This country is founded on small businesses. We can't continue to pour millions and billions into franchises that may or may not make it -- and forget the small businesses that have helped form this country as well. We must work to help all, not just the chosen.
Jane B. Fain.
Richmond.
Climate Debunking Was Bunk Itself
Editor, Times-Dispatch: In his letter, "Climate Change Needs Debunking," William Ryan certainly proved his initial point: "When it comes to the environment, especially the issue of global warming, facts are irrelevant." Clearly from his perspective, facts are indeed irrelevant.
His letter, from beginning to end, is full of falsehoods he would like us to accept as facts. Does he really believe termites produce more CO2 than humans? Does he really believe global temperatures have gone down in the past decade? A 15-minute search on the Internet shows the falsity of these "factual" claims as well as the sources of his erroneous claims.
If I wrote a letter claiming research shows the average IQ of a Democrat is 10 points lower than that of a Republican, would the editors print it? Obviously the editors use intellectual criteria and judgment in choosing which letters to print; shouldn't they use some of that same intellectual power to at least perform a cursory verification of the "facts" claimed in those letters?
Rod Elser.
Powhatan.
Reader Reactions
To me this whole thing doesn’t so much boil down to the discussion of science, the problem is what certain people would have us do based on incomplete science. These people remind me of any given episode of “House” where they send us in five different, all incorrect, directions before we find out what’s really going on - if ever. It’s tough to trust the green crowd knowing that they’re all about rationing, power and control.
The problem very well may be that Mr. Elser is getting his information from a “15 minute search of the internet.“
Ot a disgraceful alarmist film.
There are many sites that claim to prove the “falsity” of skeptic claims.
And there are just as many sources that fully support the claims proposed by Mr. Ryan.
In fact, increasingly in scientific journals and scholarly papers the tide is beginning to turn on the global warming, climate change, climage crisis, climate catastrophe and the latest-deteriorating atmosphere.
But if there is only 15 minutes for research I suggest Watts Up With That and Climate Depot for some eye and mind opening informatiom.
They are both very up to date and totally informative…
Mr. Elser - It is, in fact false that the average IQ of a democrat is 10 points lower than a Republican. A democrat’s IQ is about 30 points lower. I submit to you the guy they elected president with absolutely no critical review and the complete lack of intellectual curiosity with regards to what he’s doing to the country. The IQ of a Republican is about 10 points lower than a termite with ADD making the libertarians the smartest of the bunch.
I guess waterboarding isn’t torture. I mean, since waterboarding works and torture does not and all…...
Mr. Elser, the issue is not ‘warming’ but attempts by advocacy groups to unilaterally determine the causes of it that, oddly enough, prove very profitable for those groups. Is it a natural cycle or do anthropogenic factors contribute to it? If indeed, as you imply, anthropogenic causes are the reason, then you are simultaneoulsly suggesting those people who caused the problem can fix it…..Let’s do a thought experiment…. Let’s give the federal government the power to ‘fix’ warming like they have ‘fixed’ the economy over the last 15 years or so. God only knows what the environment will be like when they are finished with it.
Post a Comment(Requires free registration)
- Please avoid offensive, vulgar, or hateful language.
- Respect others.
- Use the "Flag Comment" link when necessary.
- See the Terms and Conditions for details.


Advertisement