Weak home building a drag on economic recovery
DEAN HOFFMEYER/TIMES-DISPATCH
Houses recently under construction in the Richmond region included these homes in New Kent County.
Published: November 18, 2009
Updated: November 18, 2009
WASHINGTON — The budding economic recovery is getting little help from the home building industry, which normally creates jobs and boosts growth as a recession ends.
Construction of homes unexpectedly plunged last month to its lowest point since April, the Commerce Department said Wednesday. The weak figures show that builders still lack confidence that buyers can soak up the glut of unsold homes already on the market — a supply magnified by a record number of home foreclosures.
The figures also illustrate how much the fledgling recovery depends on government support. Builders broke ground on fewer homes in part because of uncertainty in October about whether Congress would extend a tax credit for homebuyers. Earlier this month, lawmakers renewed the credit and extended it to more buyers.
Even with government aid, the weakness of the housing sector is dragging on the recovery.
“It will take a while before residential construction begins to contribute meaningfully to growth,“ Jennifer Lee, an economist at BMO Capital Markets, wrote in a research note.
The sluggish recovery is also holding down inflation. While consumer prices edged up faster than expected in October, they remain lower than they were a year ago. And inflation is expected to remain subdued.
The Labor Department said consumer prices rose 0.3 percent in October, a bit more than the 0.2 percent economists had expected. Core inflation, which excludes energy and food, rose 0.2 percent, compared with analysts’ expectation for a 0.1 percent rise.
The higher figure was driven by another increase in energy prices and the biggest jump in new car prices in 28 years. The price of used cars and trucks also rose by the most since September 1980.
Analysts said the jump in used car prices partially reflected the government’s “Cash for Clunkers” rebate program, which has reduced the stockpile of used vehicles since cars which qualified for that program were junked and therefore not available for resale.
The advance in both new and used car prices accounted for 90 percent of the increase in core inflation last month, government analysts said.
On Wall Street, stocks edged down following the unexpected drop in home construction and disappointing forecasts from technology companies. The modest drop came a day after major stock indicators closed at 13-month highs, including the Dow Jones industrial average, which has risen nine of the past 10 days. The Dow lost about 43 points in midday trading Wednesday, and broader indexes also dipped.
The report on home construction said building of homes and apartments fell 10.6 percent in October to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 529,000, from an upwardly revised 592,000 in September. Economists polled by Thomson Reuters had expected a pace of 600,000.
Applications for building permits, a gauge of future activity, fell 4 percent to an annual rate of 552,000 units. That was the lowest since May and missed analysts’ expectations of 580,000. But permits for single-family homes fell only 0.2 percent.
The National Association of Home Builders said this week that its housing market index remained unchanged in November, reflecting a cautious outlook from residential developers as they waited to learn the credit’s fate.
The trade association said its index stood at 17 for the second straight month. Index readings below 50 indicate negative sentiment about the market.
Buyers who have owned their current homes for at least five years are now eligible for tax credits of up to $6,500, while first-time homebuyers would still get up to $8,000. To qualify, buyers have to sign a purchase agreement by April 30.
Yet construction has been weakened as foreclosures have flooded the housing market with bargain-priced properties that sometimes sell for cheaper than builders’ costs. The number of homes under construction last month fell 3.4 percent to 560,000, the lowest on records dating to 1970.
And more than 332,000 households, or one in every 385 U.S. homes, received a foreclosure-related notice in October, according to RealtyTrac Inc.
Those trends are weighing on the economic rebound.
In an interview Wednesday, President Barack Obama said he’s worried that spending too much money to help revive the economy could undermine a fragile U.S. recovery and cause a double-dip recession. That occurs when the economy begins to recover briefly from a recession only to be dragged back under.
Obama told Fox News that his administration is weighing tax breaks that could encourage businesses to begin hiring again.
But he added that if the nation keeps adding to deficit spending through tax cuts or more stimulus spending, people could lose confidence in the U.S. economy, and that could “lead to a double-dip recession.“
Advertisement
Reader Reactions
I’d be shocked if we saw any sort of big rebound in home building in the next several years. The entire country has a vast overbuilt supply that will take years to absorb. Most homes that will be built will be substantially downsized from what they were 4 years ago. Good news you can get them on the cheap, especially in the boom cities.
And looking at the positive, this increases the pace at which homes built matches demand and continues to stabilize the overall housing market! We don’t want them building houses that can’t sell. Since when did being negative on everything become a sport?
As soon as China and Japan cease or even slow down on debt purchases, the game is up. Interest rates will go through the roof and housing market demand will trend towards zero.
This nugget of relatively good news will be long-forgotten before any real stabilization occurs.
Positively speaking, I have seen neighborhoods in Charlotte NC over the past year with 35+% of the new home built without a buyer and has been empty up to 2 1/2 years now. What a DRAG!
“””ProudAmerican24 on November 18, 2009 at 10:29 am
Do some research SCRIBE. The factors that led to the economic collapse were in place long before Bush, Obama, Bush Sr., or even Regan were in office. Both parties are equally responsible for this mess in some way.”””
VERY, VERY, VERY TRUE!
Great youtube by the by!!!
And looking at the positive, this increases the pace at which homes built matches demand and continues to stabilize the overall housing market! We don’t want them building houses that can’t sell. Since when did being negative on everything become a sport?
Typical liberal talking points that, as usual, don’t amount to anything more than blindly defending democrats, and only attacking republicans.
Do some research SCRIBE. The factors that led to the economic collapse were in place long before Bush, Obama, Bush Sr., or even Regan were in office. Both parties are equally responsible for this mess in some way.
And don’t forget, Obama said the fundamentals of our economy were strong too. He said it after being elected president, and ridiculing John McCain for saying the same thing. See you need to get off of your liberal blogs because they don’t want to report facts like that because it renders their talking points obsolete.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cLr5VfOAbmw
Ouch, the facts hurt sometimes don’t they?
That’s right, the same failed policies that got us into this mess, they want to maintain! And are PROUDLY obstructing all effort to reform.
Depends on what your definition is of reform. Some of us don’t think what the left is doing is reform, but a huge power grab by the government. You would think after 8 years of bashing Bush for his out of control spending and expansion of government size, people like you wouldn’t be hypocrites and support the same thing on an even bigger scale, simply because it’s coming from Democrats and not Republicans. The democrats have a filibuster proof majority, and control all of congress. The republicans aren’t stopping anything on Obama’s agenda.
Well, with unemployment at 10% who has money to buy a house?
So you agree Obama’s stimulus hasn’t helped anything.
Although new construction might be down, existing home sales are up tremendously. That to me, is very smart on the American people’s part. Buy existing homes at excellent prices, rather than building new houses in a down market. Kudos to the public.
Back when to challenge anything the neocons were doing was UNPATRIOTIC. (Freedom Fries) was the mantra of the day;……. Anything FRENCH was undesirable, since they didn’t want to go along with (the coalition of the willing in Iraq).
I’ll give you this one. You are correct here.
Thanks, Bush/Cheney and other assorted neocons for destroying the U S economy. Yeah, I know there are those that want to point fingers and blame others for this mess. But the current economic free fall started about 5 years ago. Back when John McCain, and others, was saying the FUNDAMENTALS of the economy were Strong.
Back when to challenge anything the neocons were doing was UNPATRIOTIC. (Freedom Fries) was the mantra of the day; promoted by Fox (not news) programming, along with Rush Limbaugh and the “CULT” at ( C STREET) to name a few. Anything FRENCH was undesirable, since they didn’t want to go along with (the coalition of the willing in Iraq). Well these vultures have come home to roost. Now the “party of no” is doing all in it’s power to maintain the status quo. That’s right, the same failed policies that got us into this mess, they want to maintain! And are PROUDLY obstructing all effort to reform. What is wrong with the American people for allowing themselves to be played as fools over and over again!
Well, with unemployment at 10% who has money to buy a house? Maybe we should ask those that brought us here. I’m sure they have the “RIGHT” answeres- NOT!!!
Post a Comment(Requires free registration)
- Please avoid offensive, vulgar, or hateful language.
- Respect others.
- Use the "Flag Comment" link when necessary.
- See the Terms and Conditions for details.


Advertisement