Outbursts of the famous: Why so rude?
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
The behavior of such public figures as Rep. Joe Wilson and Kanye West has prompted many people to ask what has become of the notion of civility.
Which of the recent incidents was the rudest? Vote in our poll
Published: September 16, 2009
Updated: September 16, 2009
In an increasingly unfiltered, anything-goes society, moments of outrageous public behavior have become frequent spectacles, embraced by the media and devoured by the public.
In the past week, U.S. Rep. Joe Wilson, R-S.C., loudly interrupted the president's speech to proclaim him a liar; tennis star Serena Williams made a not-so-friendly offer to place the ball in a line judge's throat; and rap star Kanye West continued a long string of awkward award-show moments at MTV's Video Music Awards.
Some might pass off the incidents as power tripping, but others suggest they are signs of cultural decay that mirrors an erosion of values in America.
Everett L. Worthington, a professor of psychology at Virginia Commonwealth University, suggested that the stress that goes along with public life factors prominently in such meltdowns.
"There's a lot of pressure on folks to perform, especially the sport figures and media stars," he said.
"You could argue that the pace and stress of life has increased. The gazillion-dollar contracts, the stakes that politicians have, place an enormous amount of pressure on them for long periods of time and makes it probable that at some point, they might break down."
Del. G. Manoli Loupassi, R-Richmond, called Wilson's outburst during President Barack Obama's health-care address to Congress last week "inappropriate" and "beyond the pale."
The U.S. House of Representatives voted yesterday to admonish Wilson over the comment. Loupassi said similar behavior would be wildly unacceptable in the Virginia House of Delegates.
Loupassi said West's case at the MTV awards show probably was a case of more pressure under the microscope. West interrupted country star Taylor Swift's acceptance speech for best female video and suggested that the award should have gone to singer Beyoncé.
"We're all guilty of it at some point in our lives," Loupassi said. "You just hope you don't do it on the big stage."
But it's not just celebrities, athletes and politicians.
Examples from everyday life are abundant at a time when teenagers and young adults have to be threatened with fines and disciplinary action to keep their pants pulled up and profanity is commonplace.
During the recent congressional recess, a number of town-hall meetings on Obama's proposed health-care overhaul were marred by outbursts from audience members.
Worthington said that the era of e-mails, text messages, Facebook and Twitter could be a culprit.
"We say things short and to the point now, and we don't worry about the niceties of manners and protocol," he said. "One could argue that maybe for the generation that's being trained that way, the cultural protocol of restraint has eroded to some degree."
In "Generation Me," a 2006 book by psychology professor Jean M. Twenge, the author suggests that younger generations in the U.S. increasingly are narcissistic and plagued by anxiety, depression and loneliness rooted in a divide between their expectations and reality.
But older adults, too, seem to be contributing to the death of decorum.
An example locally was the iBook sale debacle of 2005, when Henrico County residents worked themselves into a frenzy at the chance to buy $50 used laptop computers from the school system and trampled one another at Richmond International Raceway.
Late last year, a Wal-Mart worker was killed by a frenzied mob of Christmas shoppers in New York as they broke through the door for post-Thanksgiving Day bargains.
Kathy Baker, owner of the Sabot School of Etiquette in Goochland County, said manners are becoming an endangered species in the U.S.
"They still exist to those of us who care," she said, "but with the Internet and the blogging, everybody can say whatever they want. It's complete disintegration."
Baker said the recent celebrity and athlete outbursts were "indicative of what's going on in society, and it's working its way up." She added that West should be forced to sit in the back of the awards audience next time.
Baker said widespread incivility is far from a uniquely American phenomenon.
"We've joined the rest of the world thanks to the Internet and 24-hour cable TV," she said. "It's just a sign of the times."
Contact Wesley P. Hester at (804) 649-6976 or
.
Advertisement
Reader Reactions
One more thing steerler fan, STFU!!!
steelerfan, I agree whole heartedly. My mom was furious when Reagan wanted me to support his war on drugs by just saying no. I clearly remember her saying, “Who does he think he is, The Gipper?“ The teacher had to call and ask if it’s ok if the POTUS tells me to just say no. It’s a good thing she said yes. I was 10 at the time, 23 years later, still drug free!
Just to set the record straight, people weren’t in an uproar over the speech in and of itself. It was the materials sent out by the sec of ed that people didn’t agree with. There isn’t anything wrong with the President speaking to school children, but when the speech is to get them to agree to his policies and support him we have a problem.
I glanced at the picture and thought that it was one of Tony Blair, with Bob McDonnell sitting in front of him! My first thought was- when did Bob McDonnell have time to sit in the House of Commons?
Maybe they’re Clones…
Yes. Bob Barr let his ego get in the way of his judgment and ran for President as a libertarian. He was squashed badly - we’re talking Polish Cavalry vs. German Panzers - squashed badly.
I’m not sure if he went back to work for the ACLU or not.
Randy,
Do you have any idea what happened to Bob Barr? He was one straight-talking libertarian who didn’t mind telling his fellow Republicans when they were going off the deep end.
Thanks guys - see, we’re all not that far apart on most of the big stuff.
Randy, I couldn’t agree more. You have put this into words in such a way I could never have done. Thanks!
Thanks Randy, I appreciate your post.
Good post Randy. I agree 100%.
Post a Comment(Requires free registration)
- Please avoid offensive, vulgar, or hateful language.
- Respect others.
- Use the "Flag Comment" link when necessary.
- See the Terms and Conditions for details.


Advertisement