UPDATE: Toddler left in day-care van died from heat exposure
Richmond Police Department
A preliminary hearing was set for Aug. 4 for Keishawn L. Whitfield, 23.
Published: July 7, 2009
Updated: July 7, 2009
RELATED: |
A 13-month-old boy left in a day-care van yesterday died from heat exposure, the state medical examiner’s office said this afternoon.
Earlier today, a 23-year-old Richmond man was arraigned on a charge of felony child neglect in connection with the death of Andrew Johnson.
Keishawn L. Whitfield, an employee of the Yellow Brick Road Day Care & Learning Center in the 2000 block of Fourth Avenue, was arraigned by video in front of Richmond Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Judge Richard B. Campbell. The judge set bond at $20,000, and defense attorney John W. Luxton said his client, who is being held in the city lockup, likely would be freed later today.
Richmond Commonwealth’s Attorney Michael L. Herring said his office will consider whether to upgrade the charge against Whitfield, who discovered the child after returning to the van yesterday afternoon. Police responded to the emergency call at 4:30 p.m. in the 2700 block of Garland Avenue, where Whitfield lives.
Campbell scheduled a preliminary hearing for Aug. 4 and agreed to a request by Deputy Commonwealth’s Attorney Mary E. Langer that Whitfield not be allowed to have any contact with children.
Luxton described Johnson’s death as clearly an accident and said he has known Whitfield’s family for several years. Whitfield typically drove the van 3-4 times daily, Luxton said.
“I can’t imagine what happened,” Luxton said. “It was a tragedy for everybody involved, particularly for the parents of the child.”
Valerot Whitlow, the owner of the day-care center and Whitfield’s mother, attended the 5-minute video arraignment with family and neighbors. She did not make any comments after the hearing, but one neighbor, Charlene Sutton, said, “We know it’s a bad situation, and we just let God prevail.”
A neighbor who lives next door to Whitfield described the family as good, hard-working people who were distraught about what happened.
The neighbor, who declined to be identified, said he talked with Whitfield’s brother after emergency crews responded and “he was angry that it happened.“
“He was angry… because nobody noticed the child until [Whitfield] found” him in the van after returning home at 2719 Garland Avenue. The boy was still alive and Whitfield tried to resuscitate him before emergency crews arrived, the neighbor said.
“I’m just sorry it happened,“ the neighbor said. “I can’t imagine the grief that Keishawn is feeling. He’s a good kid.“
Whitfield was charged in November 2007 with possession of cocaine with intent to distribute. He initially pleaded guilty but withdrew his plea. In January, a judge found there was sufficient evidence to convict on a charge of possesision but took the case under advisement and placed Whitfield under supervision, Langer said today.
— Mark Bowes and Michael Martz
Advertisement
Reader Reactions
There is just one thing that I am trying to figure out and grasp. If this is a person’s job….HOW could you forget to take a child out of the vehicle? It doesn’t matter if the child was napping or you were in a hurry. If this is what you do on a daily basis, do your job. IF you were filling in for someone else, then for sure you would do at least a mental check list to make sure you have every child out of the vehicle. I just don’t understand anyone that can “forget” to take a child out of the car. As rushed as I was when my two children were small, there was NEVER a time that I was in too much of a hurry to remember to take them out of their car seats. I know this man will have this hanging over him and his heart for the rest of his life, but when you are responsible for another person, take it seriously.
This is such a sad things that seems to happen far to often. It baffles me that anyone could potentially “forget” a child in a vehicle. I have a 3yo and have never “forgot” to get him out of the car. And yes you can compare this situation to a Brinks driver. As it is a Brinks drivers responsibilty to “protect” the bags of money it is a child care providers responsibility to “protect” the children. What kind of “checks” did this daycare have in place? Why didn’t anyone notice this child not in class? I am sorry, I can not have any sympathy for this daycare center, this tragedy is unacceptable. Did he remember to grab his cell phone before he got out of the van? He should have know how many children were on this van to begin with and should have made sure that exact number of children were taken off of the van. My heart goes out to the parents of the child. As a parent the hardest decision you can make is trusting someone else to care for your child and once you finally make the decision to trust that person or facility you have to tell yourself everyday that your child will be taken care of. You can call it an accident or mistake all you want but the bottom line is this is neglect & irresponsibility.
No need to do anything here but pray for all involved, tragic.
Good points made by DT about bags of money never being lost etc. Be assured this worker will never legally work in daycare again. However deserving anyone is to be entrusted with the most precious cargo the fact remains: there are 15—25 cases of baby death by hypothermia, “left in cars”, a year in the USA that are not intentional. The babys are still dead but the lives of the wealthy mom, or the pastor, or the soldier are wrecked beyond therapy.
No excuses, but a little compassion. We all say we can do better, and we mostly do. But 15-25 times a summer in America this happens even though everyone knows better.
Have you ever been driving along on a familiar route, then noticed that you didn’t really “SEE” the past five exit signs, “autopilot” had taken over? This is a known phenomenon in neuro circles, and nobody is really safe. We have to take known flaws and reinforce our defenses.
I agree w/fedup.. you have to read that article.. it does explain a lot about “memory” and how things work..
Valuables actually ARE left in cabs and comparing a brinks driver to a parent or caregiver isn’t exactly an apples to apples comparison.
We have all had those gut dropping feelings when we have forgotten something important.. Did we leave the stove on? Did we accidentally throw out that important document (I have done both!). The move of car seats to the back seat and reverse facing has apparently caused this situation to happen more because the child isn’t in view. Bus drivers are supposed to do sweeps of their vehicles.. hard to say whether this was part of the procedure at this daycare and whether it was not done. It certainly is a tragedy..I can’t imagine a worse feeling to have than make a mistake like this.
HOW VALUABLE IS A PERSON?
How often do jewelers leave diamonds in taxies—or Brinks Security guards forget that half million dollars
in the truck….That’s right not very often—Never in fact—They don’t
because they are entrusted with a very valuable asset—insured and avidly protected with their lives. And yet we read all too often of distracted and immature people leaving their infants in cars to die horrible deaths—Do they value their children as much as that
Jeweler does his diamonds—or the guard the cash….or the people with the Michael Jackson memorial tickets—The answer is no—they
don’t—and we should not make broad and sympathetic excuses—for these people. Any day care employee who overlooks
a child in an auto—should not be employed taking care of children
any more than they should be employed by Brinks to look after treasure….or running the government—or any other kind of serious responsibility.
Adults are the security guards of infants—not the other way around. The examples given in the article that fedup links to—tragic as they are—are more examples of persons who should never have had a child or have been
entrusted with one—-Rushing off to work and being distracted is not an excuse. If they are that careless with an infant, they are careless or worse
in other areas. These people are guilty alright—of ignorance and selfishness;
of overlooking another human being—more important than diamonds. I’m sure each one of them—including the day-care employee had their wallets, credit cards and car keys on them at the time.They didn’t forget that did they ? Okay then.
No one can know the exact circumstances yet. I encourage everyone to exercise compassion and understand that this type of tragedy happens every summer to Americans from all classes and walks of life. There was a moving article linked here that changed my personal perception of this other-worldly tragic type of event http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/02/27/AR2009022701549_pf.html
EVERYBODY with a child in the car needs to practice against the perfect storm of frontal brain vs deep “autopilot” brain: for example, leave your cell phone on the baby seat, etc.
Please look at the linked article before pre-sentencing the person responsible.
Post a Comment(Requires free registration)
- Please avoid offensive, vulgar, or hateful language.
- Respect others.
- Use the "Flag Comment" link when necessary.
- See the Terms and Conditions for details.


Advertisement