Why Did UVa Cancel Classes Only This Time?
Published: January 18, 2009
On Jan. 20, 2005, George Bush was sworn in as president of the United States. On Jan. 20, 2009, Barack Obama will be sworn in as the 44th president of the United States. The University of Virginia decided to suspend classes on only one of these important days. Can you guess which one?
Arthur Garson Jr., the executive vice president and provost of UVa, announced by e-mail that classes will be suspended on Jan. 20, 2009 from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m., in honor of the inauguration of Barack Obama. In 2005, while I was an undergraduate at UVa, classes carried on as usual for George Bush's Inauguration Day.
UVa also will be opening the doors of the basketball arena for live coverage of the swearing-in ceremony. In his e-mail to the UVa community, Garson explains, "The coming together of a nation at the same time every four years for presidential inaugurations -- as dictated by the Constitution for noon on Jan. 20 -- is an educational moment that binds us as a nation and a people." His e-mail continues: "In order to allow our students, as well as other members of our community, to participate in this exercise in democracy, the University will suspend classes between 11 a.m. and 2 p.m. on Tuesday, Jan. 20, 2009."
Based on the actions of the UVa administration, George Bush's Inauguration Day was somehow not "an educational moment" or an "exercise in democracy." This explanation is suspect. Furthermore, neither Garson's e-mail nor the official press release announcement that the suspension of class on Inauguration Day is a new policy that will be implemented well into the future regardless of whether a Republican or Democrat is elected.
Explaining the liberal bias on college campuses can be challenging because it is often a combination of overt and covert action and inaction. The suspension of classes for the inauguration of Barack Obama -- but not for George Bush -- gives a clear example of this bias.
One might try to dismiss this suspension of classes as the deci sion of one administrator. However, this was not the decision of one man and he is not the only one defending it.
In response to further student inquiries, Carol Wood, the assistant vice president for public affairs at UVa, wrote: "As you know, the interest among young people across the nation -- regardless of their party -- was unprecedented during the recent presidential campaign. Our own students here at the University were equally as engaged and they have expressed a desire to participate in some way in Inauguration Day. Given the number of important issues facing our country and the world, students told us they wanted to hear live -- with their friends -- what President-elect Obama would have to say in his Inaugural address."
Wood celebrates the 2008 election and the youth participation in it although youth voter turnout was not as high as anticipated. Oddly, she highlights the "unprecedented" participation of young people in this election, while ignoring the fact that the main way students participated was through technology -- the same technology which will make Barack Obama's Inauguration Day speech available to students 24 hours a day.
From my experience of four years of college and almost three years of law school at UVa, I do not recall classes ever being suspended for a planned political event. For example, despite student petitions, classes carried on as normal during Election Day last year.
On Jan. 20, I plan to attend the classes for which I am paying, regardless of how college administrators weigh my interest in classes against my interest in hearing Barack Obama's speech live. I also plan to watch some of the Inauguration Day activities, but I will do so on my own time.
Karin Agness is a third-year law student at the University of Virginia and the president of the Network of enlightened Women (NeW), the nation's premier organization for conservative college women. Contact her at
.
Advertisement
Reader Reactions
Karin Agness is completely tone deaf. The US is inaugurating its first African American President. The University of Virginia was founded by a man who wrote the Declaration of Independence, but was also a slave owner. The capital of the confederacy was in the state of Virginia. Prior to the civil rights movement, segregation and discrimination were rampant in the state of Virginia. There is much more that could be added, but the main point is Karin’s total failure to understand how historic this event really is.
I’ll be watching a grand total of 0.00 hours of this inauguration. Just like the previous inaugurations. I’ve got a life to lead.
The author misses a key point: the nation’s first black president is being sworn in tomorrow! That’s why classes are being suspended. Whether republican or democrat, this event has to rank among the top 10 in American history. The historical narrative of the U.S. has largely been dictated by race, a fact that resonates acutely in the Old Dominion. Tomorrow offers an all-too-rare opportunity to celebrate, rather than lament, racial events in this country.
-Second-year UVA Law student
It’s pretty obvious why UVa canceled classes - none of the students will be there. Nobody cared when Bush was inaugurated. On Tuesday the whole world will be watching and students will not be attending class, so UVa made the only logical decision possible. It’s a matter of practicality - not politics.
Uh….. I hate to say it but this article missed the cause for this action completely.
It is not, in any way, a reflection of “liberal bias” in the ADMINISTRATORS at our colleges and universities. It is a reflection of the fact that a great majority of COLLEGE STUDENTS in Virginia are politically moderate to liberal, and voted for Obama by a 75% to 20% margin.
If the administrators had closed classes and opened JPJ Arena during the second Bush inaugeration, you would be complaining how stupid it was since only 4 students showed up, and those only right out of their Campus Crusade for Christ meeting across the street.
They did this simply because there is the student interest to do so. You may as well be asking, and you should ask yourself this now, why are 5 million people gathered in D.C. to watch Obama’s inaugeration when only 3,000 were there to see Bush in 2004.
It’s not “liberal bias” in colleges, it’s lack of interest in attending similar events on the other side.
Unless you can motivate enough college students, or anyone else for that matter, to care this much about supporting Republicans, this is the way it will be. Sorry! Life is hard, law student. Get used to it now.
The Times-Dispatch wondered—editorially—if classes would have been suspended if Justice Clarence Thomas had been the first black president.
Now comes Ms Agness charging liberal bias because classes were not suspended for President Bush’s second inauguration.
At least the editorial writer got the point; although, Minister Louis Farrakhan would be elected president before Mr. Justice Thomas.
The point is that a person who could not have attended UVA when President Dwight Eisenhower was inaugurated in 1956 has been elected president. A person whose parents’ marriage would have been illegal in Virginia in 1964 when President Lyndon Johnson was inaugurated is on the way to the White House.
I know that self-styled conservatives never pass up the opportunity to ride one of their favorite hobby horses—liberal bias in academia—but this is not your father’s inauguration. Even self-styled conservatives should get the unique, historical significance of this inauguration.
I think I am a pretty good teacher—which means I can conpensate for any thing I would have taught on Inauguration Day.
And i would pay “new money” to see Ms. Agness attending those suspended classes.
Preston M Yancy
Is anyone surprised? Colleges and university’s are full of liberals whose political ideolgies are very apparent. We pay for this as taxpayers and as parents who will do anything to send their kids to college including bloated tuitions.
Post a Comment(Requires free registration)
- Please avoid offensive, vulgar, or hateful language.
- Respect others.
- Use the "Flag Comment" link when necessary.
- See the Terms and Conditions for details.


Advertisement