REPUBLICAN VICTORY: Return to Moderate Middle . . .

» 3 Comments | Post a Comment

Virginia Republicans recaptured the political middle last week, assisted by Bob McDonnell's strong centrist campaign and adherence to a positive message of economic recovery and job creation. Democrats, meanwhile, could not overcome mounting anxiety over national Democratic policies in Washington, or a lackluster campaign by Creigh Deeds that utterly failed to energize even the party's base.

McDonnell never veered from an upbeat focus on free enterprise, jobs, and Virginia's entrepreneurial spirit. His message was strong and simple. Jobs. The economy. It resonated with voters across the state; especially among independents who aren't sure they like the change they voted for last November. He carried all but two of the state's 11 congressional districts and won in Fairfax, Loudoun, and Prince William counties -- all key demographic areas that supported Democrats in recent races and contributed mightily to wins by Mark Warner, Jim Webb, and Tim Kaine.

Virginia is a highly competitive, fiscally conservative two-party state with a stubborn independent streak. Public Policy Polling shows Virginia's electorate evenly divided among Democrats, Republicans, and independents, with about a third of likely voters identifying with each category. Republicans, hungry for a win, were highly motivated. Ironically, they were energized by the departure of their own president, George Bush, whose prolific spending and expansion of government had tarnished the Republican brand and diluted the party's message.

Independents, distressed by the economy and concerned about taxes and runaway federal spending, broke to McDonnell by nearly 2 to1. Democrats stayed home. Gone was the army of half a million young and first-time voters so captivated by Obama just one year ago. They had a personal, almost apolitical relationship with Obama. It didn't translate to Deeds.

Democrats in the House of Delegates suffered severe collateral damage, losing at least seven incumbents to insurgent Republican candidates. Four Republicans thought to be vulnerable cruised to re-election by comfortable margins. Only one Republican lost: Phil Hamilton of Newport News, who is under federal investigation for alleged corruption. The GOP is now fortified in the House, claiming 59 or 60 votes depending on the final outcome of a recount. If the new governor can lure just one or two Senate Democrats to his administration, Republicans could suddenly control state government from top to bottom. Just in time for redistricting.

Last week's balloting presents a stunning reversal of fortunes from recent Virginia election cycles.

Since 2003, Virginia Democrats have:

  • Won two consecutive races for governor;

  • Captured a majority of the state's congressional delegation;

  • Won both U.S. Senate seats;

  • Taken control of the state Senate;

  • Carried Virginia in a presidential race for the first time since 1964;

  • Gained 11 seats in the House of Delegates.

Momentum has returned to Republicans much faster and stronger than many anticipated. The pendulum is now swinging back to the right, away from national Democratic policies on energy, health care, taxes, and organized labor. Among the all-important moderate middle, there is a prevailing anti-Democrat mood that heavily influenced balloting in Virginia and presages huge losses for the president's party in midterm congressional elections next year. At least three Virginia congressmen should be very nervous: Glenn Nye, Tom Perriello, and Gerry Connolly. All three are freshmen Democrats elected last year in districts swept by the GOP ticket by as much as 62 percent.

McDonnell, to his credit, promised the day after the election that he will govern from the middle; that he will stick to moderate themes and issues he campaigned on, echoing his disciplined focus throughout the campaign. Smart. Very smart.

Because this election is not a Republican realignment. It is not a broad mandate for change. It is a reaction to what's happening in Washington and a call for pragmatic, responsible governance and a tight fist on the purse strings. It is a course correction following a long string of Democratic wins. It is a return to the middle and to a place of comfort for Virginians. As former Del. Barnie Day observed, Virginia made "a graceful veer, Bob McDonnell at the wheel, to familiarity, to where it has always been -- about two clicks right-of-center."



Clayton Roberts is president of Virginia FREE, an independent, non-partisan association committed to protecting and strengthening Virginia's prosperous business environment through the political process. Contact him at .

Advertisement

 
View More: virginia election,mcdonnell,clayton roberts,
Not what you're looking for? Try our quick search:
 

Advertisement

Reader Reactions

Flag Comment Posted by R on November 12, 2009 at 3:20 pm

I concur with Hoagie regarding moderates, as clearly “the revolution that took these people seriously would perish irrevocably (and deservedly).“.  The GOP needs a vanguard, something to inspire fear, and terror…

Flag Comment Posted by 12steprevenge on November 12, 2009 at 10:58 am

The Republican Party fears a conservative Republican Party. Why? Because they know they can’t win running on that platform. Good thing most politicians are short on sincerity (as are their most vocal proponents, it seems). If it is Democrats that are so scared, then tell me why Bob McDonnell, a conservative if there ever was one, chose to downplay those principles and portray himself as a moderate?

Heck, the Republican Party is trying its darndest to put as much distance as it can between itself and the Hoagies of the world. They want to move forward, not back. Good for them.

Flag Comment Posted by drhoagie on November 12, 2009 at 10:00 am

Those who hang out in the middle of the road tend to get run over.
The GOP has tried to venture into the area where Democrats want them;  in the middle (a moderate party).  The Democrats know when the GOP goes moderate they lose.
The GOP had a moderate in Richard Nixon, George HW Bush/Dan Quayle, Bob Dole and John McCain, to name a few.
How did that work out for the GOP? 
When you hear in the media the GOP “must go moderate” or is “losing their base because of their right leanings”, that is coming from fearful Democrats.
If venturing to the right was so disastrous for the GOP, the Democrats/Big Media would shut up and leave Sarah Palin alone instead of attacking her character relentlessly.
But they are telling you they FEAR a Conservative GOP.

Post a Comment(Requires free registration)

  • Please avoid offensive, vulgar, or hateful language.
  • Respect others.
  • Use the "Flag Comment" link when necessary.
  • See the Terms and Conditions for details.
Click here to post a comment.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Online Features
Blogs
DataCenter
Videos
Weekend
 

Advertisement