Governor’s budget proposal shows grim outlook for Va.

Governor’s budget proposal shows grim outlook for Va.

“I believe people have to be willing…to sacrifice in tough times. We’re all in this together,“ Gov. Timothy M. Kaine said yesterday.

» 17 Comments | Post a Comment

Here comes the pain.

Gov. Timothy M. Kaine yesterday presented a recession-revised budget for the next two years that closes a $2.9 billion shortfall by eliminating more than 1,500 jobs, doubling the cigarette tax, freezing state wages and making deeper cuts to education, health care and public safety.

Speaking to the General Assembly money committees in Richmond, Kaine also outlined a policy change to save money by reducing the prison population -- specifically, by not jailing people for minor technical violations of parole, and by allowing inmates convicted of nonviolent crimes to be released up to 90 days early.

"We have made the tough decisions to keep the budget balanced without any general tax increase and without compromising core services," Kaine told lawmakers at the General Assembly Building, in a meeting packed with nervous lobbyists and somber state officials.

The governor's proposal is the opening round of what will likely be a long, contentious election-year fight on state spending between Democrats and Republicans when the General Assembly convenes for a 46-day session Jan. 14.

By that time, the governor and other lawmakers acknowledged even more cuts could be necessary if the economic fortunes of the nation and the state continue to dwindle.

"I don't think all the bad news is out," said Sen. Kenneth W. Stolle, R-Virginia Beach.

Kaine's latest proposed round of cuts -- the fourth since 2007 -- would:
• cut budgets for the Virginia State Police, local police, local sheriff's offices and commonwealth's attorneys offices by 7 percent;
• trim the payroll of the Virginia Department of Transportation by 1,000 workers over the next two years through retirements, attrition and restructuring, with one-third of all cuts coming from the central office in Richmond;
• cap state spending on support staff in K-12 education in 2010 for a savings of $340 million and divert $55 million in state lottery funds from school construction to base instructional expenses;
• increase the budget cuts for state four-year colleges and universities to 15 percent in fiscal 2010;
• limit qualifications for certain services under Medicaid and freeze or reduce reimbursement rates for most health-care providers to save $418 million;
• eliminate the dealer discount tax rebate -- in which businesses are allowed to keep from 1 percent to 4 percent of the state sales tax they collect to cover administrative costs -- for a savings of $64.3 million in 2010;
• close a state training center for the intellectually disabled in Chesapeake and the last state-operated mental-health hospital for children, located in Staunton, for a savings of $47.6 million; and
• raise the tax on each pack of cigarettes by 30 cents, to generate an additional $148 million to cover increased Medicaid costs.

Kaine's budget proposal also contains limited new spending, including:
• a $26 million increase for need-based financial aid for state college students and an increase in the Community College Transfer Grant Program, which helps students transfer to four-year schools;
• a $5 million increase in the Governor's Opportunity Fund, a job creation program, plus sales-tax exemptions and income-tax credits to attract and promote "green" jobs to the state; and
• a $1 million grant to the Virginia Federation of Food Banks.

Kaine said cuts to public safety were roughly half of what most agencies had to trim, and he noted that K-12 education had been spared reductions in the first three rounds of cuts.

The governor also proposed reducing to $50,000 from $100,000 the annual tax credit that can be claimed by individuals designating land for open-space preservation. But he proposed extending the period during which they can claim the credit.

Funding for mental-health treatment, increased dramatically last year to reform the system in the wake of the Virginia Tech shootings, would be largely preserved, as would roughly $22 million in additional funding secured last year for expansion of the governor's pre-kindergarten initiative.

Kaine said the last two budget decisions he made in preparing the budget were to freeze state wages by canceling two scheduled pay raises, which will save $250 million, and to raise the cigarette tax.

He said the state spends roughly $400 million just for smoking-related costs to the Medicaid budget and the current tax on cigarettes only covered $160 million of that cost.

"That struck me as a much more prudent course than basically kicking people off the Medicaid rolls," he said.

Republican leaders said Kaine should have cut an additional $500 million to $600 million in anticipation of a greater budget shortfall that could reach $3.5 billion once year-end revenue numbers are calculated.

"If there's not resistance to this tax increase, by February I think we'll see a whole slew of other tax increases being proposed by the governor or other Democrats," said Del. H. Morgan Griffith, R-Salem, the House Majority Leader.

Republicans also questioned Kaine's proposed policy change to let nonviolent prisoners out up to 90 days early, which would save an estimated $5 million a year. Currently the director of the Department of Corrections can authorize release up to 30 days early.

"One of the advances of the last 13 years was the abolition of parole," said Sen. Ken Cuccinelli, R-Fairfax, one of three GOP lawmakers seeking the party's nomination to run for attorney general.

"This breaks with the public trust."


Contact Jim Nolan at (804) 649-6061 or .

Contact Tyler Whitley at (804) 649-6780 or .

Advertisement

 
View More: layoffs,kaine,editor's picks,budget,
Not what you're looking for? Try our quick search:
 

Advertisement

Reader Reactions

Flag Comment Posted by NB on December 19, 2008 at 5:03 pm

We go through this cycle about once a decade.  The economy falters and state revenue plummets.  Followed by massive cuts in state spending and panicky efforts to increase taxes just to keep the state budget balanced.  It keeps repeating over and over again.

The problem is that, unlike the federal gov, VA state law will not permit the state government to operate at a deficit.  If revenue drops, spending must be cut an equal amount to keep the budget balanced with no regard for the social harm that may be done. 

It’s time to break the cycle by changing the law to permit state government to operate at a deficit during difficult economic times.  The conditions under which the state can operate at a deficit should be strictly defined and full repayment required as quickly as possible once the economy improves.  There is no reason for this ugly cycle of periodic deep cuts to essential services to continue in the future.  No reason at all.

Flag Comment Posted by 12steprevenge on December 19, 2008 at 9:42 am

Mike123, That has to be the most moronic idea I’ve ever heard… cutting all state employees’ salaries by 20-30% so that no one has to get cut? Did you even stop to consider the ramifications of your proposal?

As an employee of the state, in no way living outside of my means (an 800 sq. foot house in a working class neighborhood and a used Toyota), I know I would lose my home if I took a 25% pay cut. So would many, many others. Do you want a financial crisis for a few or for many? Sorry for those who will use their jobs in these trying times, but that’s the way the cookie crumbles.

Flag Comment Posted by mike123 on December 19, 2008 at 12:14 am

Tax Alcohol? Are you kidding me? I can’t believe in this day and age we are so naive.  The ABC (Alcohol Beverage Control) in this state is owned by the State.  Would you tax yourself on your own product that you sell? 

Tobacco! Hate to see it, but I believe the tobacco company will be leaving anyways, not to another state but to another country.  The one thing that will put a tobacco company over is the employees and the unions not the taxes.  Think about it, if you own the company and employed as many people as they have.  You too would ship the company oversee’s not because of taxes, but because of cost of labor. 

To help us out of this shortfall, every state or local government employee on the payroll take a 20-30% pay cut from the top down including teachers, police, fire, EMS, to the floor sweeper for 2 years.  This will help everyone keep a job even though no one will save anything or have much, but it may prevent some from losing everything.  I believe this will work for most other companies also.  If we work together, we can get out of this ourselves without bailouts and stimulus,etc…

Just a Thought.

I hope everyone have a safe and wonderful holiday!!!

Flag Comment Posted by spector01 on December 18, 2008 at 9:25 pm

Krakar and ramgrl just provided the governor with the perfect solution. An increased tax on both alcohol and gasoline not only provides the required revenue to balance the budget, it will cause us to conserve gasoline and reduce drunken driving. That sounds like a “win” “win”. I wonder if anyone from the Governor’s Office reads these comments???????

Flag Comment Posted by Krakar on December 18, 2008 at 9:03 pm

TAX ALCOHOL PRODUCTS MORE! Time to tax this “sacred cow” and show where the real costs are to be seen!!! I propose adding a 5 cent tax, in addition to what taxes are already in place, per ounce to beer, 10 cents on wine, and 15 cents on hard liquor. There are far more drinkers of beer, wine, and hard liquor in the Commonwealth than there are smokers.  This would be a fast way to balance the budget, save and create jobs, AND save LIVES on so many fronts…families/DSS/Medicaid, roads, related medical probs, insurance costs, etc.  Give up taxing smokers into the ground since drinking causes far, far more problems and costs the tax payers more in the long run.

This is Day Three that I’ve put forth this idea and I wish people would wake up to the reality of the millions upon millions of dollars in damage and strife that alcohol causes.  Don’t get me wrong, but I’m not one who abstains from alcohol and do like a beer or a mixed drink upon occasion.  I don’t believe in bringing back the days of Prohibition either, but let’s really hit a majority with a tax than an excepted few for a change.  TAX ALCOHOL PRODUCTS!

Virginia and Guv Timmie-Boy Kaine needs to remember that it was tobacco that put Virginia on the map and what taxes were paid in for many, many years.  How soon we forget history.  Figures such is forgotten when we got a darned millionaire YANKEE sitting rather poshly in the Guv’s mansion and these hard times really don’t affect his lifestyle whatsoever!

Parting thought:  Is Kaine going to give a hoot when Phillip Morris gets tired of the games and pulls all its operations from VA, putting those workers on the street?  I don’t think so!  Phillip Morris would be one smart company to get out of here and go to a state where they’d be appreciated.

Flag Comment Posted by ramgrl on December 18, 2008 at 7:36 pm

The fact is the government (state and federal) just isn’t as bright as we’d like to believe. Here’s a solution. Simple, easy and everyone keeps their jobs. The US consumes a whopping 320,500,000 gallons of gasoline per DAY. Add a $1 federal tax to that and see how long we’re in debt after that. The state could add .50 and the fed govt .50 and the problem is gone. And if you think people won’t pay that price then remember back to a few months ago when gas was $4 or more per gallon. No one quit driving completely, they just learned to conserve more. That .50 raise per gallon would cure Va budget problem in less than a week. I don’t know about everyone else but I would definitely be willing to pay an extra .50 per gallon to get VA’s economy back on track rather than cutting back on education and public safety. Almost every other country has at least $5 per gallon gas, some countries have that much TAX on each gallon in addition to cost. This country needs to seriously reconsider its priorities.

Flag Comment Posted by spector01 on December 18, 2008 at 6:24 pm

I understand that Virgina’s law requires a “balanced budget”, but I don’t understand why cigarettes smokers are always the first who must pay the price. I’m a former smoker so this is not a “whine”. There are far more Virginians who drive than smoke. So, increase the gas tax, put tolls back on the interstate or increase the tax on the large SUVs and Mimi Vans. Of course this takes courage and will not be very popular, but it would be fair and achieve the desired outcome. No one ever said being the “Boss” was easy.

Flag Comment Posted by Rayzor on December 18, 2008 at 12:27 pm

No, Beaze, I did not see the TV reports you mentioned. I don’t watch TV news because it’s drivel. However, I do recall seeing the RTD articles about Kaine’s cuts at the mansion and so on. That doesn’t change the fact that the things I commented on in his budget plan are at odds with each other and make no sense. Also, his privileged background will always impede his ability to genuinely understand the average taxpayer. And that lack of understanding goes for pretty much anyone in politics higher than municipal government.

I’m not judging him because he’s well educated or well spoken. I respect anyone with a college degree, and Kaine certainly has proven that academically he’s got quite a background. But as for “speaking the truth” and “breaking the mold,“ well, I can’t agree with you there. He’s a typical politician: promising one thing then doing another, self-aggrandizing, and very likely marrying the right person to get him ahead…sort of a Clinton Lite (either one).

But I’m getting off topic. I stand by what I wrote originally, that his cuts make no sense at all and he’s out of touch with the people of Virginia.

Flag Comment Posted by dreamweaver21us on December 18, 2008 at 12:21 pm

One of the things that governor Kaine plans to cut is the only state funded psychiatric hospital for children. We have a complete open door policy and all children are accepted as long as a bed is available. Most private hospitals refuse many difficult and violent patients.What is going to happen to these children? These children are going to suffer.  Most of these children are not stable enough for outpatient care. I fear that this will all end in another tragedy due to a child being unable to obtain proper mental health treatment. I fear there will be some children that no doors will open for. I pray that I am 100% wrong. Thanks for your time. We should all remember that while we may not directly be affected by the lack of mental health services, but we could all be affected by the end result.

Flag Comment Posted by msfedup on December 18, 2008 at 11:50 am

Buzzorn ... you are exactly right!!! When will people open their eyes and demand a stop be put to the exploitation of America and her honest taxpaying citizens….illegals are criminals, they don’t belong here and they certainly don’t deserve to be rewarded for invading our country!! Birthright citizenship should NEVER be allowed…ever. I believe we are on the verge of the next civil war if something isn’t done soon.

Post a Comment(Requires free registration)

The commenting period has ended or commenting has been deactivated for this article.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Online Features
Blogs
DataCenter
Videos
Weekend
 

Advertisement