Obama makes health-care pitch in N.Va.
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
Obama says he wants to cover nearly 50 million uninsured Americans, to persuade doctors to stress quality over quantity of care, and to cut billions of dollars from spending.
Virginia took center stage in the national debate over health-care coverage yesterday when Debby Smith rose to tell her story to President Barack Obama.
"Good afternoon, Mr. President," the 53-year-old resident of Appalachia, in Southwest Virginia, said at the president's health-care forum at Northern Virginia Community College in Annandale.
"I'll try not to cry."
Barely clinging to her composure, Smith explained that she had been diagnosed with kidney cancer in 1998 but could not have her kidney removed because she was the only caregiver for her father, who was dying of colon cancer at the time.
Her tumor was treated with radiation -- all covered by the insurance she had with her employer. But the treatment left her unable to work. And when the tumor returned, she had no health insurance, nor did she qualify for federal disability pay or Medicaid coverage from the state.
"Now I have a new tumor," she said, her voice becoming soft. "I have no way to pay for it. . . .
" I'm just trying to figure out how I'm going to make it nine years until I'm qualified to get my regular Social Security."
The story moved Obama to ask Smith to come forward to the partitioned area where he stood. Then he hugged her.
"I don't want you to feel . . . like you're alone on this," the president told her, saying that he was going to try to find ways to help Smith immediately.
Obama called Smith "Exhibit A" in why the nation's health system needs an overhaul -- one that would include a low-cost "public option" in addition to private insurers, so everyone could have access to care.
Left to their own devices, insurance companies would cover only "the young healthy folks like Mark Warner," Obama said, pointing out the senator, seated in the front row with Gov. Timothy M. Kaine and a who's who of Northern Virginia Democratic legislators.
Obama says he wants to cover nearly 50 million uninsured Americans, to persuade doctors to stress quality over quantity of care, and to cut billions of dollars from spending.
But details on exactly how to do those things generally were lacking in his hour-long town-hall forum before a friendly, handpicked audience in a Washington suburb. The lingering questions underscore the tough negotiations awaiting Congress, the administration and dozens of special-interest groups in the coming months.
Members of Congress will debate the issue when they return Monday from a one-week recess.
Smith is a volunteer for Organizing for America, Obama's political operation within the Democratic National Committee. She obtained her ticket to the event through the White House.
For many in attendance, Smith's story is not unique.
"We've done some wonderful things in Virginia, but we're working at the margins," Kaine told the audience before Obama took the stage. "Because in Virginia and in the nation, one in seven Americans and one in seven Virginians don't have health insurance.
"And those that do have health insurance often find serious difficulties in cost and access and quality."
Virginia Secretary of Health and Human Resources Marilyn B. Tavenner said she frequently sees cases like Smith's. "We're going to see if we can put something together to get her care," she said in an interview after the forum.
During the forum, White House aides selected questions submitted by people on YouTube, Facebook and Twitter.
Contact Jim Nolan at (804) 649-6061 or
.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Advertisement
Reader Reactions
National health care is easy. Just give everyone the same coverage we are giving congress and the house. If those worthless bums deserve it so do we. After all, we are PAYING for it.
The independently-funded healthcare policy research organization, The Commonwealth Fund, compared possible savings ‘a health insurance exchange’ could bring under three different scenarios. One would include a Medicare-like plan along with private insurance. Another would instead offer only a government-run plan with rates somewhat higher than Medicare. The final one would be private insurance with no government plan at all.
Commonwealth’s study found cumulative health system savings between 2010 and 2020, compared with projected trends for that period, would range from $3.0 trillion under a Medicare-like plan along with private insurance paying providers at Medicare rates in competition with private plans, to $2.0 trillion for a public plan paying providers at rates between Medicare and private plan rates, to $1.2 trillion in the private plan-only scenario. All three options would help insure nearly all Americans, it said, with the number of uninsured dropping to about 4 million people by 2012. ‘Such an exchange’ would offer a central point for consumers to shop for and compare health plans.
Under the Medicare-like plan along with private insurance, all U.S. residents would be required to obtain health coverage. The plan would establish a new government-sponsored health program for people younger than age 65 who are not eligible for Medicare. More than 40 million people would be expected to enroll in the program, according to Cathy Schoen of the Commonwealth Fund.
The government-operated insurance exchange would be similar to an existing program in Massachusetts and would allow people to compare coverage offered by private insurers and the new public program. In addition, the plan supports wide adoption of health information technology, better disease prevention efforts and ‘changes to the insurance payment system’ that promote efficiency. Health spending would continue to increase under the plan, but at a slower rate than current projections over the next 10 years. The Commonwealth Fund said the plan would reduce annual health care spending growth from a projected 6.7% to 5.5% and save a cumulative total of about ‘$3 trillion’ by 2020, adding a national health insurance exchange program that includes a federally managed health insurance option could potentially save $1.8 trillion more than a plan consisting only of private plans.
The group’s analysis assumed other changes would also be made to the U.S. healthcare market. These include an expansion of existing government coverage and new regulations that would require insurers to cover a wider range of consumers. Hospitals and doctors would also see their revenues grow with any of the three exchanges but at a slower rate, the report said.
The proposal’s advocates have argued that a government-sponsored insurance plan would offer the 46 million uninsured Americans an affordable alternative to costly private insurance, adding that It would provide a strong incentive for private plans to strealine, innovate and compete.
Obama is no Bill Clinton. He can’t stage these events and make them believable to anyone paying attention.
But we do have to give him credit for not bringing up the “poor” lady who “couldn’t afford to feed her kids” again.
You know, the lady with the obese kids standing by her side.
‘Smith is a volunteer…for Obama’s political operation.‘ Sad to say, I knew before the article was over the other shoe would drop on this person’s story. These ‘town meetings’ are getting old, especially when after all the orchestration it turns out there’s no ‘there’ to Obama’s plans. He’s all smooth words, hugs and ‘concern’. I care to, but I don’t count because my ‘care’ is not the ‘care’ Obama and the Democrats want. They only ‘care’ as long as they gain more power, more control and more wealth.
Why don’t we call this what it reall was? an infomercial. When you only invite people sympathetic to your cause in a staged event.. it can’t be called anything else. (not saying that there has never been a “planted” question ever.. but this was 100% staged by all accounts) I have said it before.. it is a tragedy when a serious illness or disaster strikes a family or person. However, what makes the tragedy of her cancer, or the Katrina victims housing loss any more deserving of assistance than someone who’s bread winner died in a car accident or who’s home was destroyed in a fire when they had no insurance? As much as we would like to think we can “heal the world and help everyone”, we just can’t.. Bad things happen to good people.. and we just can’t fix it all so that no one is ever sad. That is a nice thought, but it is not realistically possible. Will some people fall through the cracks.. sure.. just like there are children abused in this country every day.. It shouldn’t happen, but it does. There are a lot of reasons why people don’t have insurance.. and some of it does come down to choice as there are people that are willing to take the risk that they won’t get ill. In fact, there are actually a lot of people in the “uninsured” numbers that would actually be eligable for existing healthcare plans like medicaide or medicare. Why not make the system we have work more efficiently?
The Green Party stands for joining the REST OF THE WORLD in single payer health care, while the Republicrats are for more insurance and hospital profits.
http://gp.org/press/pr-national.php?ID=226
Greens call for new GAO, Congressional Budget Office studies on Single-Payer health care
That poor woman. Sick and seeking help from the last group of people who can and will help her. Democrats.
Obama, in a staged moment, said to the cancer stricken Debby Smith; “We are going to try to find ways to help you immediately”
What does “immediately” mean?
To rationale people, an “immediately” pledge would mean “without delay”.
But Obama and his posse have known of Ms Smith and her plight way back in December of 2008.
If anyone in the Obama camp had an ounce of compassion, they would have privatly set forth and pointed her in the right direction in how to utilize the umpteen social programs we have out there to provide for the uninsured.
Or point her in the direction of a private church, where people pool together to help one another.
But they chose to use this dying woman as a pawn. To allow her time to look more sickly and more desperate, just to pull her out at the opportune moment when the cameras are rolling.
If she does not survive, will anyone be charged with murder by omission?
Interesting.. while Governor Kaine was sitting in this meeting helping to promote another government proposal we can’t afford, 10 disadvantaged youth had to cancel their fishing trip at the local state forest. My husband watched a gentleman come in with a group of city kids to the local convenience store to buy blood worms for their fishing adventure.. When he was informed of the $15.00 per person fee, his face fell.. he didn’t have that much money.. The kids were so down hearted.. he had to put the bloodworms back and they left.. Sort of ironic that this is the governor who touts camping in our state parks.. now I guess it’s only for the “rich”.
Go Figure:
Private Health Insurance Companies will WIN BIG here because high risk policy holders will be guided straight to the Public Plan…
There’ll be some kind of competitiveness clause, plus a Mandatory Insurance Mandate—thus the insurers will go down in history as some kind of legendary bandits…!!!
WHAT???!!!
ALL other developed countries have implemented Single-Payer Health Insurance, but here in the USA we have too many politicians with NO-HEART!!!
Post a Comment(Requires free registration)
- Please avoid offensive, vulgar, or hateful language.
- Respect others.
- Use the "Flag Comment" link when necessary.
- See the Terms and Conditions for details.


Advertisement