Aaron Stone walked into the store and looked toward the pictures on the wall. Hugo Bradby, owner of Noah’s T-shirt Shop in South Richmond, asked Stone for whom he was looking. Stone wanted to see his nephew, Jalier Burleigh, who was shot and killed June 10, 2007, at age 19. Bradby pointed to Burleigh’s picture. “The way that he died—it was uncalled for,“ Stone said. “Nothing I can do about that.“

DUBLIN, Ohio—Beneath a gray sky and dreary rain, thousands of colorful umbrellas framed both sides of every fairway at Muirfield Village. On a miserable day to watch golf, no one was about to miss a single shot. Not with Jack Nicklaus in his familiar crouch, grinding over a birdie putt that everyone wanted him to make. Not with Tiger Woods, down to his last shot, delivering in the clutch with a 12-foot par everyone knew he was going to make.